In an impervious area, dust, dirt and other constituents are built up on street surfaces in periods of dry weather preceding a storm. Build up may be a function of time, traffic flow, dry fallout and street sweeping. During a storm runoff event, the material is then washed off into the drainage system. Although the build up/wash off option is conceptually appealing, the reliability and credibility of the simulation may be difficult to establish without local data for calibration and validation (Huber and Dickinson, 1988).
When the build up/wash off option is used in SWAT+, the urban hydrologic response unit (HRU) is divided into pervious and impervious areas. Management operations other than sweep operations are performed in the pervious portion of the HRU. Sweep operations impact build up of solids in the impervious portion of the HRU. For the pervious portion of the HRU, sediment and nutrient loadings are calculated using the methodology summarized in Chapters 4:1 and 4:2. The impervious portion of the HRU uses the build up/wash off algorithm to determine sediment and nutrient loadings.
The build up/wash off algorithm calculates the build up and wash off of solids. The solids are assumed to possess a constant concentration of organic and mineral nitrogen and phosphorus where the concentrations are a function of the urban land type.
Build up of solids is simulated on dry days with a Michaelis-Menton equation:
6:3.4.1
where is the solid build up (kg/curb km) days after the last occurrence of kg/curb km, is the maximum accumulation of solids possible for the urban land type (kg/curb km), and is the length of time needed for solid build up to increase from 0 kg/curb km to (days). A dry day is defined as a day with surface runoff less than 0.1 mm. An example build-up curve is shown in Figure 6:3-1. As can be seen from the plot, the Michaelis-Menton function will initially rise steeply and then approach the asymptote slowly.
Wash off is the process of erosion or solution of constituents from an impervious surface during a runoff event. An exponential relationship is used to simulate the wash off process (Huber and Dickinson, 1988):
To convert the sediment loading from units of kg/curb km to kg/ha, the amount of sediment removed by wash off is multiplied by the curb length density. The curb length density is a function of the urban land type. Nitrogen and phosphorus loadings from the impervious portion of the urban land area are calculated by multiplying the concentration of nutrient by the sediment loading.
The two parameters that determine the shape of this curve are and . These parameters are a function of the urban land type.
6:3.4.2
where is the cumulative amount of solids washed off at time (kg/curb km), is the amount of solids built up on the impervious area at the beginning of the precipitation event (kg/curb km), and is a coefficient.
The coefficient, , may be estimated by assuming it is proportional to the peak runoff rate:
6:3.4.3
where is the wash off coefficient (mm) and is the peak runoff rate (mm/hr).
The original default value for was calculated as 0.18 mm-1 by assuming that 13 mm of total runoff in one hour would wash off 90% of the initial surface load. Later estimates of gave values ranging from 0.002-0.26 mm. Huber and Dickinson (1988) noted that values between 0.039 and 0.390 mm-1 for give sediment concentrations in the range of most observed values. They also recommended using this variable to calibrate the model to observed data.
Street cleaning is performed in urban areas to control buildup of solids and trash. While it has long been thought that street cleaning has a beneficial effect on the quality of urban runoff, studies by EPA have found that street sweeping has little impact on runoff quality unless it is performed every day (U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, 1983).
SWAT+ performs street sweeping operations only when the build up/wash off algorithm is specified for urban loading calculations. Street sweeping is performed only on dry days, where a dry day is defined as a day with less than 0.1 mm of surface runoff. The sweeping removal equation (Huber and Dickinson, 1988) is:
6:3.4.4
where is amount of solids remaining after sweeping (kg/curb km), is the amount of solids present prior to sweeping (kg/curb km), is the fraction of the curb length available for sweeping (the availability factor), and is the removal efficiency of the sweeping equipment. The availability factor and removal efficiency are specified by the user.
The availability factor, , is the fraction of the curb length that is sweepable. The entire curb length is often not available for sweeping due to the presence of cars and other obstacles.
The removal efficiency of street sweeping is a function of the type of sweeper, whether flushing is a part of the street cleaning process, the quantity of total solids, the frequency of rainfall events and the constituents considered. Removal efficiency can vary depending on the constituent being considered, with efficiencies being greater for particulate constituents. The removal efficiencies for nitrogen and phosphorus are typically less than the solid removal efficiency (Pitt, 1979). Because SWAT+ assumes a set concentration of nutrient constituents in the solids, the same removal efficiency is in effect used for all constituents. Table 6:3-5 provides removal efficiencies for various street cleaning programs.
Table 6:3-6: SWAT+ input variables that pertain to build up/wash off.
Variable Name | Definition | Input File |
---|---|---|
IURBAN
Urban simulation code
.mgt
URBLU
Urban land type identification number from urban database
.mgt
DIRTMX
: maximum amount of solids allowed to build up on impervious areas (kg/curb km)
urban.dat
THALF
: number of days for amount of solids on impervious area to build up from 0 kg/curb km to
urban.dat
URBCOEF
: wash off coefficient (mm)
urban.dat
CURBDEN
curb length density in urban land type (km/ha)
urban.dat
TNCONC
concentration of total nitrogen in suspended solid load (mg N/kg)
urban.dat
TPCONC
concentration of total phosphorus in suspended solid load (mg N/kg)
urban.dat
TNO3CONC
concentration of nitrate in suspended solid load (mg N/kg)
urban.dat
SWEEPEFF
: removal efficiency of the sweeping equipment
.mgt
FR_CURB
: fraction of the curb length that is sweepable.
.mgt